New Amsterdam
Mar. 5th, 2008 09:46 amIt's a little early to tell if this show will be of comparable caliber to the Sarah Connors Chronicles, but it has some potential:
1) He named his dog "36". It's a lovely little detail about what immortality really means.
2) He forges (?) his own antiques. If you age your own work to make it look like furniture pieces you made decades ago, is it a crime?
3) The "knowing everything" thing might get a little old. He's not "John Doe", but I suppose you do pick up on thing in 400 years.
4) He's completely open about how long he's lived, but no one ever believes him. They think he jokes. This is hysterical.
5) The hidden workplace/batcave is great. The wall of catalog cards was especially impressive, I thought.
6) The romance angle ought to drive the plot-arc along, but hopefully won't consume the entire show.
7) The trailer for Thursday's episode made a Highlander joke! :-P
8) Speaking of Highlander, this show seems to have a better grasp of the _continuity_ of history. Highlander was about "Ago" and "Now." But New Amsterdam tried several times to show the actual flow of years around the main character. His photo essay of Time Square (?) was especially poignant.
9) Speaking of Highlander again: he's had kids! Much different Immortal!Angst than McLeod's infertility!angst.
10) Speaking of history: good call on New York. Lots of time and events there to dig into.
11) For someone who keeps complaining about the ennui of immortality, John does seem to keep himself busy and enjoy life (if only in a low-key way). OTOH, I suppose that's the only way to _combat_ the ennui of immortality. Still, I have a hard time feeling sorry for someone who seems to have everything together (except a soulmate).
To sum up: They treat the "immortality" theme with respect and whimsy, but it remains to be seen if the rest of the show can match up to it. I'm glad we've got another episode on Thursday to evaluate.